Who is Neil Pierre? The USMNT giant with the potential to rival Pau Cubarsi

Analysis

Tom Weber | Writer

The United States men's national team kicked off the new World Cup cycle with a resounding victory over Peru at the weekend, and the team's new golden generation took centre stage.

Head coach Mauricio Pochettino handed 11 of the 13 uncapped players he called up their debuts in Orlando as the US cruised to a comfortable 4-1 victory on home soil. Two of the debutants, Justin Ellis and Julian Hall, even got on the scoresheet.

The crop of prospects now breaking through is the best the US has ever had. Man City-bound Cavan Sullivan, who celebrates his 17th birthday today, headlines this group, but he is far from the only potentially generational talent.

Among the debutants in Orlando was centre-back Neil Pierre, who was one of three Philadelphia Union youngsters to make his senior USMNT bow, alongside Sullivan and right-back Frenkie Westfield.

He only played a handful of minutes against Peru, but there is undoubtedly more to come. That's because Pierre is not just one of the biggest talents in the US pool, but one of the best in the world.

Pierre has best-in-the-world potential

A Pennsylvania native, Pierre is also eligible to feature for Haiti due to his parents. At just 18, the young defender has now firmly nailed down a starting spot at Philadelphia, and many feel that this should actually have happened much sooner.

Alongside Sullivan, Pierre has been one of the biggest prospects in the Union's best-in-class academy setup for years. However, first-team opportunities were previously hard to come by.

On the one hand, this is understandable because it is rare for teams to trust teenage centre-backs. On the other hand, it was blatantly obvious that this was a major mistake by previous Union head coach Bradley Carnell.

Trusting homegrown talent has been Philly's modus operandi for years, yet the South African was reluctant to put his faith in Sullivan and Pierre in the early stages of this season - and he ultimately paid for it with his job.

After losing defensive rock Jakob Glesnes to the LA Galaxy in the offseason, the Union made the bizarre call to loan Pierre to Danish second-tier outfit Lyngby because Carnell didn't want to use him.

Recent history has shown that this was a ridiculous decision. While the Union were one of the worst teams in MLS in the first half of the season, Pierre helped Lyngby get promoted to the top flight.

He returned to the Union in the summer and entered a radically different environment. Carnell had been sacked and replaced by Ryan Richter, who was promoted from reserve team head coach to interim boss.

Because of his background and previous work with many of the Union's young guns, the team has been turned on its head. Sullivan and Pierre have played outsized roles in recent weeks, and they have handsomely repaid Richter's faith.

Sullivan has undeniably been one of the best performers in all of MLS since the beginning of August, while Pierre has started all but one league game for the Union since his return in July. Remarkably, Richter has won 10 of the 12 MLS matches he's taken charge of, not losing a single one.

Even at the weekend, when the Union had to make do without their new USMNT stars, they put four past Orlando City in an easy 4-2 win. Incidentally, four is also how many goals Pierre has already scored for Philly since coming back.

That's because the 18-year-old is a cheat code on set pieces. Standing at an incredible 6 ft 7 in, Pierre is the obvious target on corners and free kicks. However, there is so much more to his game than just being very tall.

Pierre is excellent on the ball and incredibly athletic for a player of his size. Of course, at just 18, he still needs to improve his reading of the game, and mistakes are inevitable, but he has all the attributes to become an incredibly well-rounded, world-class defender.

That's also backed up by data from analytics firm SciSports, which ranks Pierre as one of the top U21 prospects in the sport - and in any position. Only Barcelona sensations Lamine Yamal and Pau Cubarsi have a higher potential.

Indeed, were it not for Cubarsi and his absurd ceiling, Pierre would be the best centre-back talent in the world. The Union starlet has made "rapid" positive development over the past six months, with SciSports ranking him among the best-performing centre-backs in MLS.

What next for Pierre?

Naturally, Pierre is attracting widespread attention due to his performances and potential. The Union have already planned ahead to 2027 by pre-agreeing a January deal for Mark McKenzie to return to the club after a few years in Europe, most recently with Toulouse.

McKenzie will either replace Pierre in the offseason or mentor him until the summer, when a move to Europe is perhaps more likely. Regardless of the timing of the transfer, it is inevitable that Pierre will head back across the pond eventually.

While there will undoubtedly be high-profile interest, SciSports' Career Advice tool suggests that Pierre shouldn't rush into joining one of Europe's biggest clubs. While he has sky-high potential, his current ability is not yet believed to be at elite Premier League or LaLiga level.

Consequently, SciSports suggests a transfer to a stepping-stone club. Tyler Adams' side Bournemouth are his top option with a Club Fit rating of 82 out of 100, followed by Real Sociedad, who are coached by New Jersey native Pellegrino Matarazzo.

Aston Villa, Leeds, Crystal Palace, Everton, Fulham and Newcastle also get decent scores.

Related stories:

Wrexham’s €40m bid rejected: Lyon star snubs ‘Hollywood fairytale’

Trent Alexander-Arnold is destined to return to Liverpool

Transfer Rumours: Barcelona chase Chelsea ace Estevao as €25m release clause revealed

Written by

Tom Weber | Writer

Tom Weber is an experienced, multilingual sports writer who specialises in European football and American soccer as part of his freelance work for FootballTransfers.

View full bio