Liverpool's Achilles Heel that could RUIN their season

Muhammad Butt
  • 4 Sept 2025 21:00 BST
  • 6 min read
Arne Slot Gravenberch Liverpool Achilles Heel
© IMAGO

Liverpool are top of the Premier League having won three out of three games.

Article continues under the video

The Reds beat Newcastle at St. James' Park, overcame a tricky tie against Bournemouth and even beat Arsenal at Anfield. All this after beating Crystal Palace in the Community Shield.

Then they followed this up by signing Alexander Isak from Newcastle for a massive €144 million, taking their total spent in the summer transfer window to over €450 million. They are looking imperious, but are they?

Current ETV
Player image Ryan Gravenberch
Ryan Gravenberch

DM, M (C)

Liverpool logo

Liverpool

Ryan Gravenberch
Ryan Gravenberch

DM, M (C)

Liverpool

Liverpool

€86.1M

ETV Range

€77.5M - €94.7M

The defending Premier League champions spent more than any other club in the world this summer to reinforce their squad and prepare for the future. They could barely be stopped last season, what's to stop them running the table now they've made their team even stronger? Surely nothing stands in their way, right?

Wrong.

Arne Slot's Chaos Football

Firstly there is just fate. Football is chaos, and sometimes things just go wrong for no real reason. Managers and sporting directors do what they can, but chaos is undefeated.

But looking at the team they've assembled, it's absolutely delightful to watch in attack, they drive forward and in numbers and Hugo Ekitike looks a much more devastating finisher than even Liverpool would have expected him to do.

Things have been going great for Arne Slot at Liverpool.
© IMAGO - Things have been going great for Arne Slot at Liverpool.

Their wing-backs fly up the pitch and they overwhelm opponents with fast movements and laser-sharp shooting.

But as good as they are in attack, they are for sure weak at the back.

While Jeremie Frimpong and Milos Kerkez are athletic upgrades at wing-back, neither is a good defender. Moreover neither has the playmaking intelligence of Trent Alexander-Arnold, who departed the club in the summer.

The Reds relied a great deal on Trent's long-range passing ability to get the ball into the final third and to their danger men in attack. Without the Englishman things do not progress as consistently and at the same tempo as they did before.

Current ETV
Player image Trent Alexander-Arnold
Trent Alexander-Arnold

D (R)

Real Madrid logo

Real Madrid

Trent Alexander-Arnold
Trent Alexander-Arnold

D (R)

Real Madrid

Real Madrid

€68.5M

ETV Range

€61.7M - €75.4M

But back to defence, in order to accomodate Florian Wirtz into the starting XI, Dominik Szoboszlai will have to drop out. Injuries have thus far allowed Liverpool to avoid addressing this issue, but it is going to need addressing.

Szoboszlai is so important because of his ceaseless defensive effort. Last season he and Luis Diaz provided an enormous defensive counterweight to help ensure Liverpool weren't overran. Diaz is gone now and does Szoboszlai get into the first choice XI?

Current ETV
Player image Dominik Szoboszlai
Dominik Szoboszlai

M (C), AM (L)

Liverpool logo

Liverpool

Dominik Szoboszlai
Dominik Szoboszlai

M (C), AM (L)

Liverpool

Liverpool

€81.1M

ETV Range

€73M - €89.3M

All of which could be counter-balanced, perhaps, if Liverpool had a monster sweeper in defensive midfield. Think N'Golo Kante, Javier Mascherano, Claude Makelele, etc.

They don't. They have Ryan Gravenberch.

Liverpool's Achilles' Heel

The thing is, Gravenberch was an excellent defensive midfielder last season. With Diaz and Szoboszlai providing their superb effort, he was able to be a mostly effective defensive midfielder as he was largely on the front foot.

However, this season, when Liverpool start putting out XI's without either of those men, you'll see Gravenberch being asked to cover a lot more ground and on the back foot, too. He'll be in reactive mode, which doesn't suit him at all.

STATS
Player image Ryan Gravenberch
Ryan Gravenberch

DM, M (C)

Liverpool logo

Liverpool

Ryan Gravenberch
Ryan Gravenberch

DM, M (C)

Liverpool

Liverpool

All Tournaments

2024/25

  • 55

    Games

  • 0

    Goals

  • 5

    Assists

Gravenberch is a defensive midfielder in the Busquets-mould, which means that you need to keep up a relentless press to allow him to defend in a way that best suits him.

Liverpool have yet to do that this season, and unless they do (highly unlikely given their new signings and how they all play) then Ryan Gravenberch is going to be Liverpool's Achilles' Heel this season.

Not because he isn't good, he's great, but he'll be stretched to his limit by the structure of the side and having to be in reactive mode all the time. Especially when his back-up is Wataru Endo, a lovely lad but not someone you'd want starting games, especially games of consequence.

Ryan Gravenberch is essential to the way Liverpool play.
© IMAGO - Ryan Gravenberch is essential to the way Liverpool play.

An injury meant Gravenberch wasn't seriously involved with Liverpool this season until the Arsenal game. And without the Dutchman they conceded six goals across those three games, and plenty more chances besides. With him? A clean sheet (albeit aided by Arsenal's own profligacy).

Gravenberch is so critically important to Liverpool's defence, especially as they failed to add Marc Guehi to their defence too (though not for lack of trying).

Is there an answer?

Yes. Sort of.

Arne Slot's Diamond solution

If the structure would expose Gravenberch, change the structure!

Switch to a 4-4-2 diamond. This formation allows for your wing-backs to be as attacking as possible while Gravenberch remains at the base of midfield. But this time, he'll have Alexis MacAllister and Dominik Szoboszlai and Florian Wirtz with him.

Current ETV
Player image Alex MacAllister
Alex MacAllister

M (C)

 logo

Alex MacAllister
Alex MacAllister

M (C)

€0.1M

ETV Range

€80K - €0.1M

The diamond midfield allows Gravenberch to hold while MacAllister and Szoboszlai move up and down the pitch, while Florian Wirtz remains on the field to wreak havoc as a 10. This provides security, plus the added pressing from Szoboszlai will prevent Gravenberch from being over-exposed.

Another bonus of this formation is, in theory, it allows both of Liverpool's €100 million strikers on the field at the same time as a devastating pairing of sharp movement and clinical finishing.

Although for now Mohamed Salah would likely take one of those striker spots, but in terms of building for life after Salah, the 4-4-2 diamod sets Liverpool up kind of perfectly.

Or Arne Slot's Reds can stick with 4-2-3-1, play some immaculate attacking football and make a tonne of defensive mistakes that eventually opponents are going to start punishing with a devastating regularity.

And that could absolutely ruin their season.

Football transfer news headlines today

Why Arsenal must SACK Mikel Arteta if they don't win the Premier League

OFFICIAL: Chelsea sent UEFA message over Garnacho BAN after transfer controversy

EXCLUSIVE: Mainoo leaves Amorim fuming as Man Utd miss out on Gallagher

The summer’s most EMBARRASSING transfer blunder? Premier League stars go VIRAL

Fabrizio Romano Transfer News: Fermin to Chelsea TRUTH, Mainoo CONFIRMATION, Sancho DETAILS

The FootballTransfers app

Check out FootballTransfers' new app for all of football's big storylines, transfer rumours and exclusive news in one convenient place directly on your mobile device.

The FootballTransfers app is available on Google Play and in the Apple App Store. Download here:

Google Play

App Store

Never miss the next big transfer!

Get the latest transfer insights and analyses directly in your mailbox.